Charlie Jade recap: “Betrayal”

See, I told y’all stuff was gonna happen, right? Holy hellfire! While this episode has some very nice character moments slipped in, it’s really all about story. A lot gets pushed forward, some ideas that had been dropped for weeks get brought back to the forefront where they belong, and we say goodbye to at least one old friend. Despite all the spackle the new writers had to use to hide the gaps between the old way and the new, this episode crackles.

Before we jump in, don’t forget to check out our exclusive interview with head writer Alex Epstein.

Karl Breaks

We’re leading off with Karl because this episode is all him and Tyrone Benskin knocks it out of the park. Karl serves two important purposes on the show. He’s our proxy - the dumb character who needs to have things explained to him so they can be explained to us - and Charlie’s guide. Those are both thankless tasks. If you’re always laying pipe, it can be hard to get anything meaty to do.

Tonight, Karl gets one of the meatiest stories this show’s done. Reena’s torture gave Patricia McKenzie a lot to work with, but nothing quite like Karl’s breakdown in the woods. The sight of him collapsing before the prospect of being necklaced was something else. His fear came to life in that scene, breathing the gasoline fumes right alongside him. It was a really nice touch by the sound editors playing crowd noise beneath the early part of the scene, climaxing with the sound of a tire bursting into flames.

Serpentine and cold-blooded, Langley Kirkwood’s Ren Porter doesn’t need to yell to be frightening; he’s scariest when he smiles. The little look of frustration he gives when the first match doesn’t light might be my favorite moment in an episode filled with great moments. The banality of it, in contrast to the horror with which Karl is being threatened, makes it that much more real.

Karl’s final betrayal, leaving Charlie at Kunjani like Jesus at Gethsemane, was his most painful. Surely he knew in the woods that Ren was right: even if Karl didn’t talk, they’d find out about Charlie eventually. But here…I think Karl had really convinced himself that they just wanted to talk with Charlie. Seeing the guns and realizing his role, it’s a wonder he didn’t hang himself.

Charlie Was an Official Pastry Judge

Maybe it’s just me, but Charlie’s irritation and impatience with himself tonight seems like a commentary about the progress of the show to this point from Robert Wertheimer and the new writers. He’s irritated that he’s been sitting around wasting his time instead of digging hard into Vexcor. That’s a similar assessment to the one we’ve had. Rather than being an active agent in his story, Charlie’s been sitting back, waiting for people to come to him.

I’m exaggerating to a point, but the first eight episodes were far less about Charlie looking for answers than they were about Charlie reacting to Beta. Even in “Diamonds”, where he and Karl learned Vexcor is planning to implant chips in everyone, Charlie didn’t make his discovery through some deep investigation of Vexcor. He made it trying to get back his stolen ring.

Tonight, Charlie’s taking the fight straight to Vexcor.

A drive around town with Karl to take photos of Vexcor construction sites turns up nothing unusual. They could be up to something nefarious, or could just be expanding. Then it hits him. Mapping the sites, Charlie sees they form a perfect circle under Cape Town. Vexcor is replacing the link site in the desert with an even larger site right under the city.

While Karl has his encounter with Ren, Charlie checks out Vexcor’s home office. Unable to get past the building’s firewalls from the outside, he sneaks in. First he overhears some employees discussing Julius’s new office - the “temple” - and the link home. then he connects his phone/tricorder/sonic screwdriver to the network. What I couldn’t tell was whether he tapped and took it, or if he left it connected for now.

Regardless, Charlie heads underground. Karl’s been burned and would be in too much danger if he stayed around, and Charlie needs to sow confusion within Vexcor by making them wonder if he’s an employee of one of their Alphaverse competitors.

This also means Charlie’s going to have to stay away from Paula for now, but she makes that both easier and harder by telling him to stay away permanently. He stalks her and almost decks her dad and she thinks he’s dreamy. He kills a few Vexcor security agents in her restaurant and suddenly he’s bad news? Man, women are fickle.

Realistically, Paula’s been a complication that doesn’t add much to the story, so it’s no wonder the writers took this opportunity to get rid of her. More time for Jasmine, now.

01 ♥ Essa

We started off this week where we left off at the end of “Devotion”, with 01 Boxer wounded and hopped off to Gamma.

By the way, this might be the best, last chance to see that third tap in the shower. So rewind and take a look.

01 stumbles into a beach house, bloodied and weak, and makes his way upstairs. As he collapses, a woman sees him and screams. Knowing 01’s history with the fair sex, we might assume this poor woman is frightened by the intrusion of the strange, bleeding man. That’s a nice bit of sleight-of-hand from the writers, as we’ll find out by episode’s end that the woman is in fact 01’s wife and mother to his two children.

The crazy sociopath is a loving family man in Gamma. Bet my wife wishes *I* lived in Gamma. Hell, 01 probably takes out the trash without being asked, he’s so downright decent in that ‘verse.

So what gives? Well, we know that 01’s trying to protect Gamma from whatever evil plans Vexcor has for it. That’s one reason for him to put himself through the obvious torment of the other ‘verses. In addition, last week we saw the bargain he’s made with the devil, his father, to trade his blood for his mother’s remaining possessions. Presumably all the bargaining power Brion Boxer has over his son revolves around those items.

From his fever dreams, we can see 01 is not a man happy with who he is. Filled with provocative images and an underlying Oedipal theme, his convalescence is more for the psychic wounds he’s suffered so long away from home than the physical injuries. Reborn by episode’s end, 01 looks ready to tackle Vexcor, his father, and Essa with newly restored clarity of purpose and sanity.

Reena and her Party Dress

Speaking of provocative images, this is the first time we’ve seen Reena smile since…um, I guess that set of photo booth pictures? Seriously? It took over two months to let Patricia McKenzie smile. Two months of misery, pain, torture (literally), and guilt. Tonight she smiled. And wore a dress. Personally, I think she should wear dresses all the time, but that’s got less to do with Reena and more to do with my crush on P-Mac.

This week she did have to come to grips with the loss of Rosalie, but knowing her friend’s gone to a better place makes it easier on her. Burying her in the backyard was probably not amongst her happiest moments in life, but if the body is just a vessel, she can take comfort that Rosalie’s soul has transcended.

We also had a few small signs of what’s to come ahead. The water in Rosalie’s house appears to be turned off. Presumably other essential services - phone and electricity - will be soon to follow. Beyond that, Reena knows she’s but a temporary guest here. She can’t stay too long before someone realizes what’s happened. She figured that out when she skipped to answer the phone, then let it keep ringing.

Reena’s going to be moving on soon. But at least she’ll have money from her new job at Vexcor thanks to Rosalie’s final gift: her identity.

Final Thoughts

Charlie’s going to go back to the mystery of Elliot Krogg. Specifically, what was in Krogg’s report? That’s probably pretty important, as the rogue scientist thought the link was too dangerous to bring up. With Reena inside Vexcor, there should be some interesting events unfolding. Her new job in the mailroom should allow her access to most everyone and everywhere in the building, so it’s going to be interesting to see how “the new face of terror” gets around without being noticed.

Finally, Karl. He’s pretty f’d up right now. It’s going to be a rough road ahead for him.

What did everyone else think?

R.A. Porter is an aspiring television writer who currently toils away in the software mines. He can be found at his personal blog and stalked on Twitter.

Advertise with Pop Critics

6 Responses to “Charlie Jade recap: “Betrayal””

  1. I still prefer Paula over Jasmine. Disappointed to see her go.

    Great recap. The progress of the show definately shows through your writing. Things are finally moving forward.

    Two of my favorite scenes are Karl getting apprehended by the agents and the shoot out at Paula's restaurant.

  2. I'm still very confused by Boxer 01. He is clearly a product of Alpha, and in Alpha and Beta he is totally psychopathic. But for some reason he's 'normal' in Gamma. This makes no sense, and needs to be explained since neither Charlie nor Reena have exhibited any personality changes.

    I viewed this episode more along the lines of things being tied up and pieces set in place. Not sure how much we'll see of Karl, and from your synopis it looks like the end of Paula but if I hadn't read that I wouldn't be writing her off just yet. It seems she means more to Charlie than Jasmine did, but I guess that will be clarified in the weeks ahead.

  3. > “I'm still very confused by Boxer 01. He is clearly a product of Alpha, and in Alpha and Beta he is totally psychopathic. But for some reason he's 'normal' in Gamma. This makes no sense, and needs to be explained since neither Charlie nor Reena have exhibited any personality changes. ” :

    “PC: It’s pretty clear early in the run that 01’s behavior is closely tied to the verse he finds himself in. Your team obviously carried that forward, as well as showing some growth to his character even in Beta and Alpha. Why does no one else seem effected by the different verses? Did you know, or was Wertheimer keeping that close to the vest?

    AE: I don’t think we meant that he was magically affected by the world he was in. Gamma’s just a much saner world; and much further from Brion, his father. I think he was saner because he was happy there.”

  4. @Tempus, Alex Epstein gave us his take on 01's behavior in our interview last week. @Dontlk has excerpted that below. But I'd go further and disagree with your statement about Charlie and Reena. I think Reena *does* act differently in Beta.

    She's barraged with noise and images and horrible smells. Things don't taste as good, the air isn't clear, and the people are dangerous. She's constantly on edge and wary. It might not be as severe as 01's changes, but Reena isn't getting closer to the man who defiled *her* mother, either.

  5. “It was a really nice touch by the sound editors playing crowd noise beneath the early part of the scene, climaxing with the sound of a tire bursting into flames.”

    “By the way, this might be the best, last chance to see that third tap in the shower. So rewind and take a look.”

    “But at least she’ll have money from her new job at Vexcor thanks to Rosalie’s final gift: her identity.”

    Richard, thanks for catching and mentioning these little tidbits of important information that I missed. Another wonderful recap to assist me in fully understanding what went down in the episode. I have to stop watching the show so late in the evening… I’m missing too many details.

    I also liked the small touch of the first match (or was it two) not lighting and subsequent frustration on Ren Porter’s face during Karl’s interrogation scene. It’s so brief and yet other (lesser) shows with a similar scenario would’ve just let the first match ignite and attempted to make it more corny dramatic by showing a close up of it lighting. Well done.

  6. Hey there. Interesting story about this ep, esp the attempted necklacing. We scripted a more explicit version. Cultural differences, man…the South African crew and the director wouldn't do it. They wouldn't put the tire on his head and stuff — they told us “it's too loaded a symbol for South Africans.”

    Anyway, so we get the rushes back and it looks like they cut to the tire and it looks kind of like Lubinsky is scared of…….a tire!

    So the whole sound fx thing was an imperfect solution to communicate what we were going for when we wrote it.

    A year later or so I watched the 2nd season premiere of The Shield, and they did a necklacing in the teaser — and it was brutal, and awesome and exactly how we wanted it. And I thought, “Wow. It was a good idea.”

    Moral of the story: always know the mores and feelings of where you're shooting.

    R.A. I've looked for an email link but couldn't find it — just wanted to say that these recaps of yours are wonderful. Really great stuff. (Found em through Alex's blog.)

    Best,
    Denis McGrath
    Writer, CJ

Leave a Reply

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.